logo



RESEARCH GUIDE SERIES:   RESEARCH GUIDE NO. 3B

Guide3B.gif - 13543 Bytes


Cleveland Law Library Association members and those entitled to privileges under O.R.C. Section 307.51 can access the most
currently available information on jury verdicts and settlements throughout the country. Reference to print and online verdict reporting
services and settlement-related materials provides a resource for evaluation, preparation and resolution of comparable cases.
The verdict and settlement databases may also identify who the expert witness was in a particular case.
More databases are available to assist in locating an appropriate expert witness.

3B_Verdict.gif 3B_Settlement.gif 3B_Expert.gif
JURY VERDICT SERVICES

These services typically summarize case facts and theories of liability argued to the jury and include names of expert witnesses, settlement demands and offers, and verdict amounts. The Law Library subscribes to the following:

I. ONLINE RESOURCES FOR FEE

  • Both LEXIS and WESTLAW provide databases which contain verdict and settlement information. Aside from the specialized files, newspapers and periodicals are fertile sources for locating specifics about settled cases and verdicts which rarely find their way into case reporting systems. U.S.A. Lawyers Weekly also has an electronic database of verdicts nationwide, available to subscribers. Casemaker also has jury verdict databases.
  • LEXIS (Public Records > Public Records > Courts & Filings > Jury Verdicts & Experts)

    The Law Library subscribes to the Lexis Verdicts & Dockets Library. Members have free access to this material, but a library staff member must run the search for you. The Lexis Verdicts & Dockets Library much more than the items listed here for illustration.

    • Ohio Trial Reporter (OHJURY), JAS Publications, 1987-
    • Many jury verdict reports for different states and the District of Columbia
    • Jury Verdicts and Settlements, Combined (ALLVER) - contains all the state databases combined, including Ohio Trial Reporter.
    • National Jury Verdict Review & Analysis (NTLREV)
    • Verdicts, Settlements & Tactics (VERST) 1988-
    • Medical Litigation Alert (MDALRT) Oct 1992-
  • WESTLAW (Partial list of databases in the library's plan)

    • Jury Verdicts - National JV-NAT: Includes Jury Verdict Research, Inc., 1987-1991; LRP Publications, Inc., 1991 to the present and more individual state verdict reporters.
    • Ohio Jury Verdicts All -OH-JV-ALL: The most comprehensive Ohio Jury Verdict database. Includes the following three databases, described below: Ohio Jury Verdicts Combined, West's Ohio Jury Verdicts and ALMVS Ohio Verdicts.
    • Ohio Jury Verdicts Combined OH-JV: Includes JAS Publications, Inc. Ohio Trial Reporter;Jury Verdict Research, Inc.; LRP Publications, Inc. and Jury Verdicts Review Publications, Inc.
    • West's Jury Verdicts OH-WEST-JV: Not included in Ohio Jury Verdicts Combined.
    • VerdictSearch Ohio Jury Verdicts and Settlements ALMVS-OH-JV: Not included in Ohio Jury Verdicts Combined.
    • Ohio Jury Verdicts Plus OH-JV-PLUS: Same databases as Ohio Jury Verdicts Combined, but also includes cases from the states in the Sixth Circuit.
    • Combined JAS Jury Verdicts and Settlements JAS-JV
    • Employment Law Verdicts JV-EMPL
    • Personal Injury Jury Verdicts and Settlement Summaries (JV-PI)
    • Jury Verdict & Settlement Summaries (LRP-JV) 1987-
  • Ohio Verdict Reporter - (Casemaker)

    • Available via Ohio State Bar Association's Casemaker database. Coverage is from 1976 to the present, although there appears to be time lag of about one year.
  • U.S.A. Lawyers Weekly

    • Lawyers USA Verdicts: "Lawyers Weekly Verdicts is a compilation of verdicts and settlements reported in Lawyers USA and our various state newspapers. The collection contains more than 19,000 reports, some dating as far back as 1989." Additionally, attorneys may submit verdicts they have won for inclusion in the database. Recent Ohio verdicts are included, although Ohio Lawyer's Weekly has ceased publication around 2005.

II. PRINT RESOURCES

  • A. Ohio

    • OATL Verdict Reporter, Ohio Academy of Trial Lawyers, 1995 to date. KFO197 .P3 A46. - Reports state court settlements and verdicts. Focus is on personal injury.

    • Ohio Trial Reporter, JAS Publishing, 1987 to date in print; KFO47.1 O3. - Summarizes Ohio civil jury trials from Common Pleas and U.S. District courts. Entries are indexed by county, subject matter, attorney, expert witness, injury, judge, and insurance carrier, but there are no cumulative indexes.

    • Ohio Damages Awards: Personal Injury & Intentional Torts; Analysis of Specific Dollar Awards by Type of Injury or Action, Lawyers Cooperative Publishing Company, 1993 to 2000. (Not currently published.) [W.BALC.] KFO90.D3 034.

    • Justice Center Reporter: Publication started in 2002. Published sporadically, about once a month. Contains Cuyahoga County verdicts, arranged by type of case.

  • B. National

    • Personal Injury Valuation Handbooks, Jury Verdict Research, Inc., 1989 to date. KF1256.A8 J87x

      Contains tables for each type of injury showing the "basic injury value" corresponding to the amount of medical expenses. The Case Evaluation Manual contains adjustment figures for admitted liability, personal characteristics of the plaintiff and defendant, and county deviations. There are also trend statistics, such as the annual range of awards and median award for specific types of injuries, percentage of cases where punitive damages were awarded and recovery probability over the years. There are also annual statistics for different types of injuries showing the length of time from filing to disposition. The last volume of the set contains the National Verdict Survey - Ohio Edition. These annual reports are indexed by expert witness, injury, and type of liability.

    • Dollar Verdicts: Personal Injury. West Group, 1998 to date. - "Only reported cases which have generated a published opinion are presented." Arranged by type of injury. Includes Occupational Injury Index and Punitive Damages Index.

    • National Jury Verdict Review and Analysis, Jury Verdict Review Publications, Inc., 1989 to date. KF1247.8 N36. - Coverage includes medical and professional malpractice, products and premises liability, insurance, and miscellaneous cases. This publication is not well indexed.

    • Verdicts, Settlements and Tactics, Shepards/McGraw-Hill, 1981 to date. KF446 .V47. (Vols. 1-8 were published by the Litigation Research Group as Verdicts and Settlements.) This service reports personal injury verdicts nationwide and includes indexes to Subject Matter, Medical Expert Witnesses, Non-medical Expert Witnesses, Jurisdiction plus a Table of Cases.

    • What's It Worth?: A Guide to Current Personal Injury Awards and Settlements, Michie Company, 1992 to date. KF1257 .M9. - Annual compilation arranged by type of injury, then within that by state. There is also an index by jurisdiction.

    • Products Liability Reports: Volume 2, CCH, 1963 to date. KF1296.A6 C6. - In the "Damages Award" tab, contains verdicts organized by type of product. Comes in handy when looking for verdicts on a broad category of products, for example medical devices, for which online searching may be difficult.

    • American Law of Products Liability: Product Citators, Clark, Boardman Callaghan, 1987 to date. KF1296.A54. - Has sections dealing verdicts and cases for particular types of products. Comes in handy when looking for verdicts on a broad category of products, for example medical devices, for which online searching may be difficult.

III. FREE INTERNET RESOURCES


SETTLEMENT TREATISES

EXPERT WITNESSES

I. PRINT RESOURCES

II. FREE INTERNET RESOURCES

III. ONLINE RESOURCES FOR FEE

  • LEXIS

    • Partial List of databases in the library's plan.
      • Combined Expert Directories (ALLEXP)
      • Legal Expert Pages (CAEXPT)
      • Midwest Directory of Expert Witnesses & Consultants (MWEXPT)
      • AMI Physician Directory (AMIDIR)
      • Forensic Services Directory. (EXPERT)
      • The Official American Board of Medical Specialties. (ABMS)
      • The Verdict databases, listed above, will likely list the name of the expert in the case.
    • Not in the library's plan
      • Lexis Nexis Analyzer: Searches verdicts, cases, articles, etc. simultaneously

  • WESTLAW

    • Partial list of databases in the Library's plan.
      • Legal Expert Pages (CA-LEP)
      • The Verdict databases, listed above, will likely list the name of the expert in the case.
    • Databases not in the library's plan:
      • Profiler Expert Witness database (PROFILER-EW): not included in the library's "free" plan. May contain a list of articles written by the expert and cases in which the expert participated.

  • DEFENSE RESEARCH INSTITUTE

    • Defense Research Institute: Free for members of DRI. Lists articles and cases for each expert. For an additional fee, you may get email delivery of articles, transcripts and/or curriculum vitae.

The Law Library staff can help with search formulation for any of the above databases. If you have questions about any of the materials in this guide, ask a staff member at the front desk for assistance.

Anne S. McFarland, Esq.
Reference & Research Services Librarian
September 2002
Updated: March 2005

home
BACK TO
RESEARCH GUIDES


Created on: September 12, 2002 -
copyright